Thanks to a Morris County energy partnership, local governments
receive access to renewable energy for a portion of their energy
needs at a price below what they are paying, and they have no
obligation on the debt.
Morris County has created a renewable energy program through the
unique powers of its Improvement Authority. The goals of the
program are to:
provide renewable energy, starting with solar panels, for local governments in the county on a turnkey basis,
with no capital cost passed on to the local units,
at operating costs lower than existing utility rates, thereby resulting in operating budget certainty and savings for its local government participants.
Based on these goals, the county has heard from over 40 local
units that are interested in installing solar panels on over 7
million square feet of roof space, which equates to roughly 20
megawatts (MW) of renewable energy. Morris County is doing its
part to realize the state's Energy Master Plan goal that by 2020,
30 percent of the state's electricity needs are to be provided
from renewable energy sources.
The county has sought a county-wide geographic reach in its
initial pilot program. We are presently in the process of
receiving proposals pursuant to the state's competitive
contracting procedures under Local Public Contracts Law. This
pilot program seeks to provide 3 MWs of power on as many as 16
local and county buildings for five boards of education, the
county, and the county's Park Commission, along with certain
capital improvements related to these panels, such as roofing
improvements and electrical upgrades.
The cost of this pilot program is still to be determined through
the competitive RFP process, though the state's Local Finance
Board has approved Improvement Authority bonds of up to $30
million for this pilot program.
While other local governments have either financed solar programs with tax exempt bonds or entered into turnkey relationships with private solar developers (no longer can these private contracts be sole sourced; Local Finance Board notices 2008-20 dated December 3, 2008 and 2009-10 dated June 12, 2009 require use of the competitive contracting procedures of the Local Public Contracts Law), the county's program seeks to take advantage of the benefits of both options, while minimizing the drawbacks.
Since government can generally access capital at costs cheaper
than the private markets, the Improvement Authority is proposing
to issue bonds to finance this program that are guaranteed by the
county and its AAA rating. This program has been run through the
rating agencies, which are supportive and have upheld the
county's AAA rating.
The private solar developer sector, on the other hand, can take
advantage of federal tax benefits (such as the 30 percent
investment tax credit and five year advanced depreciation on 25
year assets), and is experienced in optimizing the monetization
of solar renewable energy credits (SRECs) obtained through the
state's Board of Public Utilities for producing renewable
energy.
These benefits have been combined in the county's renewable
energy program. The authority enters into a series of license
agreements with its local governments that want renewable energy,
in order to gain access to their roof space. After the Authority
issues its AAA county guaranteed bonds to finance the solar
projects, the Authority leases the solar panels to a
competitively procured solar developer, structuring that lease
purchase in such a manner as to convey tax ownership to the
private solar developer (a determination made by the private
party).
The solar developer, in turn, makes lease payments to the
Authority to fully pay the debt service on the Authority bonds.
Through a power purchase agreement (PPA), the private solar
developer sells the electricity generated by these solar panels
(having been leased to the private solar developer) through the
Authority back to the local units at a rate below the existing
utility tariff rate. Finally, the county is asking that the solar
developer produce a letter of credit, or some functional
equivalent, to ensure that if the county guaranty is ever called
upon (e.g., due to a failure by the solar developer to make its
required lease payments that service the bonds), the county is
repaid in full. The county is exploring whether the Federal
Department of Energy loan guarantees can be a realistic
substitute for this security.
This structure in effect allows the private market to do what it
does best, take advantage of the benefits (such as tax, SRECs,
PPA price) and assimilate the burdens (pay the debt and produce
security, like a letter of credit) of the renewable energy
program, and embed all of that and convert it into a turnkey
sales price for renewable energy that is attractive to local
governments.
At the end of the day, the local governments get renewable energy
for a portion of their energy needs at a price below what they
are paying, and they have no obligation on the debt. This reduces
local operating budget expenses (in addition to providing budget
certainty for the 15 year life of this program under existing
law), and doesn't require bond approval. The county is lending
its rating to this process, in order to provide the lowest cost
of capital, thereby ensuring that the local governments can
receive a below tariff electricity rate. Moreover, the solar
developer gets the incidental benefit of earning a fair return
(in part, thanks to the federal tax and state energy benefits),
and the county is protected from downside risk by the security
provided by the solar developer.
This hybrid model can be expanded to other forms of renewable
energy, including wind, hydro-electric, geothermal and others,
albeit with differing financial implications due to varying
federal and state incentive programs. The county plans to work
through its local government demand for the program before it
addresses whether it shall expand the program (which is legally
permissible) to not-for-profit organizations. Pricing can be
further lowered should the state determine to extend the maximum
PPA life from the present 15 years, to 30 years, as the state
Legislature did this past June for county colleges (only) under
the state's stimulus bill.
The Federal government could further lower the cost to local
governments should it expand the present Build America Bond
program, presently providing 35 percent of the interest cost on
bonded debt to be paid by the Federal government, to this type of
renewable energy structure.